There is some precedent in other jurisdictions. About 5 years ago, the GL of Arkansas "de-petitioned" a candidate who professed himself as an ordained Wiccan, (
http://masonicleaks.com/tag/ordained-wiccan/).
The reasoning behind this is a number of edicts incorporated into the Arkansas Masonic Digest which define just what the Grand Lodge considers to be the "one true and living God"... e.g. that God is not a "force" or materialistic animus as many paganistic beliefs typically describe. Arkansas has codified some guidance in that regard, nd this is probably the same sort of thing that the GL of Florida is trying to do...
Extracted from the Arkansas Masonic Digest, 2012 ed.:
3.7.16 Belief in God and in the immortality of the soul is a cardinal doctrine of Masonry, and it is the sense of the Grand Lodge of Arkansas that the God of Masonry is the Great Architect of the Universe, the Creator and Preserver of all things, the God of the Bible as well as the God of those who know nothing about its teachings; that the God of Masonry is not a God - a force - a materialistic cause, but the one true and living God to whom we must all account; and that anyone rejecting these great truths is unworthy of initiation into, or of holding membership in, a Lodge of Free and Accepted Masons. -Pro. 1879, p. 65; amended Pro. 1951, p. 70.
3.7.17 A belief in a Supreme Being is required of all candidates for the mysteries of Masonry. No atheist can be made a Mason. -Pro. 1877, p. 11.
3.7.18 Being a deist is not a disqualification for initiation; but the applicant must believe in God and the immortality of the soul. -Pro. 1879, p. 16.
3.7.19 One who believes in God, but does not believe in the Bible, can be made a Mason, if otherwise worthy. -Pro. 1867, p. 46.
3.7.20 Hereafter when a candidate presents himself for initiation, before being prepared he shall make affirmative answer to the following question, "Do you seriously declare upon your honor that you believe in the existence of one True and Living God, and in the immortality of the soul?" -Pro. 1907, p. 87.
3.7.21 Masonry does not bar any man on account of membership in any church. - Pro. 1935, p. 23.
3.7.22 A member who, in fear of death, joined the Roman Catholic Church, and for the sake of receiving the benefits of the ordinances of that church renounced Masonry, but afterwards recovered and desired to resume his connection with the Fraternity, ought not for said cause to be expelled. Masonry proscribes no man on account of his politics or religion. - Pro. 1880, p. 28-29.
When I took the vows of a Scottish Rite Mason, I promised, among other things, to be a "soldier of liberty" and a "soldier of religious tolerance" on behalf of all mankind... not just within the fraternity. Every person has, or should have the right and privilege to approach his or her Deity in the way they best see fit. But does that also mean that someone, for example, who bows down before the baalim, dances before an Asherah pole, passes their children through the fire to Molech, or otherwise worships the starry hosts would make a Mason? Or someone who senses some animus in the trees and bushes, or spirit of nature?
When I was passed and raised, I also made some promises about following the rules in my local lodge and ultimately within my grand lodge's jurisdiction, which are the rules set forth in the Digest noted above. If we ever get to be the Grand Master, I might look at those rules and how they might hurt someone, but until then, I've got some promises to keep.
